Notifications
Clear all

Insurance paid way less than what it cost me to replace my roof

447 Posts
421 Users
0 Reactions
6,645 Views
Posts: 5
(@jondiver)
Active Member
Joined:

Yeah, I learned the hard way about that whole actual cash value vs. replacement cost thing. When my garage roof got trashed in a hailstorm, I figured insurance would cover most of it, but they only paid out for what the old roof was “worth” after depreciation. Ended up paying a lot more out of pocket than I expected. I didn’t even think to check about code upgrades either—turns out the city made me add extra venting and better shingles, which wasn’t covered.

It’s wild how many little details are buried in those policies. I get wanting to save on premiums, but sometimes those cheaper policies come back to bite you. Now I keep a folder with receipts and photos just in case, but honestly, I wish I’d known all this before. Live and learn, I guess...


Reply
Posts: 12
(@tiggercalligrapher)
Active Member
Joined:

It’s wild how many little details are buried in those policies.

- Been there. I thought “insurance is insurance,” but the fine print is brutal.
- Actual cash value vs. replacement cost is a sneaky one. I only found out after my neighbor’s water heater flooded his basement and he got way less than he needed.
- Code upgrades are another gotcha. If your city changes the rules, you’re on the hook unless you have “ordinance or law” coverage. Most people don’t even know that’s a thing.
- Keeping receipts and photos is smart, but I’d also check if your policy has any weird exclusions or limits—sometimes it’s buried in the endorsements section.
- Honestly, paying a bit more for better coverage might be worth it, even if it feels like a ripoff at first. Learned that the hard way too...


Reply
mcampbell10
Posts: 11
(@mcampbell10)
Active Member
Joined:

Yeah, the fine print is where they really get you. I used to think “I’ll never need all that extra coverage,” but after a fender bender where my policy didn’t cover half the rental costs, I’m way more cautious now. It’s frustrating, but you’re right—sometimes paying a bit more upfront saves a ton of headaches later.


Reply
Posts: 7
(@guitarist30)
Active Member
Joined:

That’s a tough lesson, but honestly, it happens more than people realize. The devil’s in the details—especially with roof coverage. Step one is always to check if your policy covers replacement cost or actual cash value. Replacement cost pays for a new roof, while actual cash value factors in depreciation, which can be a huge difference. Next time you renew, ask about endorsements or riders that fill those gaps. It’s not always cheap, but it can save you from nasty surprises down the road.


Reply
buddyleaf174
Posts: 14
(@buddyleaf174)
Active Member
Joined:

Step one is always to check if your policy covers replacement cost or actual cash value.

Yeah, learned this the hard way too. I’d add—don’t just rely on what the agent says over the phone. Ask for it in writing, and actually read the fine print. I once thought I had full replacement, but turns out there was a “cosmetic damage” clause that limited coverage. Now I keep a checklist: policy type, exclusions, deductible, and any endorsements. It’s tedious but beats getting blindsided later.


Reply
Page 69 / 90
Share:
Scroll to Top