Notifications
Clear all

lower premiums vs higher coverage—what's your sweet spot?

68 Posts
63 Users
0 Reactions
292 Views
kennethcamper
Posts: 5
Topic starter
(@kennethcamper)
Active Member
Joined:

Been crunching numbers lately, trying to trim down monthly expenses, and insurance is kinda giving me a headache. Right now, I'm torn between dropping my coverage a bit to save on premiums or sticking with the higher coverage and just sucking up the cost each month. I mean, on one hand, cheaper premiums feel great every month when bills roll in, but then there's that nagging worry—what if something actually happens and I'm left wishing I'd kept the better coverage?

My brother-in-law swears by minimal coverage. He's like, "Dude, I've saved hundreds every year!" But he's also the guy who thinks expired milk is just a suggestion date, so...yeah. Meanwhile, my coworker had a minor accident last year and was super glad she had the higher coverage because it saved her from a big out-of-pocket hit.

I'm curious how others here approach this balance. Do you lean towards saving month-to-month with lower premiums or prefer paying extra for peace of mind?

67 Replies
mcampbell10
Posts: 1
(@mcampbell10)
New Member
Joined:

"My brother-in-law swears by minimal coverage. He's like, 'Dude, I've saved hundreds every year!' But he's also the guy who thinks expired milk is just a suggestion date, so...yeah."

Haha, this cracked me up because I know someone exactly like that. But seriously though, going minimal on insurance always feels like gambling to me. Sure, you might save a few hundred bucks each year, but one unlucky moment can wipe out years of savings in an instant. A few years back, I got rear-ended at a stoplight—totally not my fault—and the other driver had bare-minimum coverage. Guess who ended up paying out-of-pocket for repairs and medical bills? Yep, me.

Ever since then, I stick with higher coverage. It's annoying seeing that premium each month, but honestly, the peace of mind is worth it. I'd rather budget around a predictable monthly expense than risk a huge surprise bill down the road. Cutting corners on insurance feels a bit like skipping seatbelts to me—you're fine until you're suddenly not.

Reply
gaming692
Posts: 3
(@gaming692)
New Member
Joined:

I get your point, but honestly, higher coverage isn't always just about peace of mind—sometimes it's a necessity. I've owned luxury cars for years, and trust me, even minor fender-benders can cost thousands to repair. Think about it:

- Luxury car repairs aren't cheap—specialized parts, certified mechanics...it adds up fast.
- Minimal coverage might save you money short-term, but one accident involving a high-end vehicle could easily surpass those savings.
- Also, liability limits matter more than most people realize. If you're at fault in an accident with a pricey car or serious injuries involved, minimal coverage could leave you personally responsible for the difference.

I'm all for saving money where it makes sense (expired milk aside...), but insurance isn't the place I'd choose to gamble. It's not just about feeling secure; it's financially smart if you're driving something expensive or have assets worth protecting.

Reply
Posts: 3
(@aspen_hall)
Active Member
Joined:

"Minimal coverage might save you money short-term, but one accident involving a high-end vehicle could easily surpass those savings."

Yeah, learned that lesson the hard way on a road trip through Colorado. Friend of mine clipped a Tesla—minor scratch, major headache. Definitely shifted my thinking toward better coverage after that...

Reply
kennethcamper
Posts: 5
Topic starter
(@kennethcamper)
Active Member
Joined:

I'm actually shopping around for my first insurance policy right now, and honestly, this thread is making me lean toward better coverage. I'd rather pay a bit more monthly than stress about potential big bills later... peace of mind counts for something.

Reply
Page 1 / 14
Share:
Scroll to Top