Notifications
Clear all

Why did my GEICO premium jump so much this year?

495 Posts
468 Users
0 Reactions
11.9 K Views
Tampa_Tony
Posts: 17
(@tampa_tony)
Active Member
Joined:

Yeah, I’ve noticed the same thing—my renewal had a couple of “extras” tacked on that I never asked for. It’s wild how they just assume you won’t check. Shopping around every year is a pain, but it’s saved me a few hundred bucks more than once. Loyalty discounts are basically a myth at this point.


Reply
jose_miller
Posts: 16
(@jose_miller)
Active Member
Joined:

Loyalty discounts are basically a myth at this point.

Ain’t that the truth. I’ve seen folks stick with the same company for years, thinking they’re getting some secret “good customer” deal, but nope—just a slow-motion wallet drain. The “extras” they sneak in are wild too. Last year, my own policy tried to add roadside assistance... for a car I barely drive. Gotta love the creativity. Shopping around’s annoying, but it’s like a weird annual tradition now.


Reply
aaronsinger
Posts: 3
(@aaronsinger)
New Member
Joined:

Shopping around’s annoying, but it’s like a weird annual tradition now.

Yeah, it’s wild how much rates can jump for no real reason. I used to think sticking with one company would pay off, but after my premium shot up last year (no accidents, nothing changed), I started comparing every renewal. Found a better deal with a different provider—almost $300 less for the same coverage. Loyalty just doesn’t seem to matter much these days.


Reply
athomas31
Posts: 10
(@athomas31)
Active Member
Joined:

Yeah, it’s crazy how the “loyalty discount” feels more like a myth these days. I’ve seen folks stick with one company for years, only to get hit with random hikes. Here’s what I do now:

- Compare at least 3 quotes every renewal.
- Double-check coverage details—sometimes the fine print changes.
- Don’t be afraid to call and ask for a review; sometimes they’ll magically “find” discounts.

It’s a pain, but it’s saved me a chunk of change. Loyalty’s nice, but my wallet wins.


Reply
baking844
Posts: 15
(@baking844)
Active Member
Joined:

Honestly, I’ve seen the same thing happen with my own policy. Last year, I called in and mentioned my spotless driving record, and suddenly they “found” a safe driver discount that wasn’t there before. Makes me wonder—has anyone actually seen their rate go down after an accident-free year, or is it just wishful thinking?


Reply
Page 93 / 99
Share:
Scroll to Top