Notifications
Clear all

Renting a car: stick with GEICO or pay for the rental company’s insurance?

199 Posts
192 Users
0 Reactions
6,173 Views
Posts: 12
(@joshuahistorian)
Active Member
Joined:

The photos and video trick has saved me more than once... can’t believe how much they try to pin on you if you’re not careful.

That’s honestly the best habit you can have with rentals. I’ve seen folks get dinged for scratches that were there before they even picked up the car—one guy I know got charged for a “missing” floor mat. He had video proof it was never there, and that saved him a headache.

I hear you on the “loss of use” fees. They’re buried in the fine print, and most people don’t realize their regular policy or credit card might not cover it. I’m always a little skeptical about the rental company’s coverage, though. Sometimes it feels like they’re just upselling peace of mind. But, like you said, for specialty cars or overseas, it’s a different ballgame. I’ve seen claims get messy when you’re out of the country.

Honestly, double-checking your own insurance and card benefits is the way to go. It’s a pain, but it beats getting stuck with a bill you didn’t expect.


Reply
Posts: 11
(@paulc38)
Active Member
Joined:

I’m always a little skeptical about the rental company’s coverage, though. Sometimes it feels like they’re just upselling peace of mind.

That’s been my experience too. I once handled a claim where the customer thought their card covered everything, but “loss of use” wasn’t included. The rental company’s coverage felt overpriced, but it actually saved them in that case. It’s not always clear-cut—sometimes you pay for peace of mind, sometimes you really need it.


Reply
reader33
Posts: 9
(@reader33)
Active Member
Joined:

Yeah, I get where you’re coming from. I’ve been burned by fine print before—thought my regular insurance had me covered, but the rental company found a loophole. It’s annoying, but sometimes that extra coverage really does save your butt. Still feels like a gamble, though.


Reply
Posts: 18
(@kathym80)
Eminent Member
Joined:

I totally get the frustration with the fine print—been there myself. Rented a convertible for a weekend road trip once, figured my classic car policy would cover me since it’s with the same company as my regular insurance. Turns out, nope, they had some weird exclusion for “temporary use vehicles” that I totally missed. Ended up paying out of pocket for a scratch that wasn’t even my fault. Ever since then, I’m super cautious and usually spring for the rental company’s coverage, even if it feels like overkill.

But I always wonder—are those extra fees really worth it, or am I just being paranoid? Has anyone actually had a rental claim go smoothly with just their regular insurance? I keep thinking maybe I’m just overthinking it, but then again, I’d rather be safe than sorry. The whole thing just feels like a bit of a trap sometimes... anyone else get that vibe?


Reply
Posts: 10
(@becky_white)
Active Member
Joined:

Had a similar run-in last year—thought my GEICO policy would have my back, but when the rental got a door ding, it turned into a circus. The adjuster wanted all sorts of documentation, and the rental company kept tacking on “loss of use” fees. In the end, I paid more than if I’d just shelled out for their coverage. Feels like a racket, but after that mess, I’m way less trusting of my regular insurance for rentals. Still bugs me though... are we just paying for peace of mind?


Reply
Page 37 / 40
Share:
Scroll to Top