Notifications
Clear all

Deductibles and premiums—what's the real deal?

236 Posts
227 Users
0 Reactions
3,613 Views
maxt23
Posts: 13
(@maxt23)
Active Member
Joined:

Yeah, “regional risk factors” is basically code for stuff like more accidents, thefts, or weather claims in your zip code—even if you personally had a clean year. It’s frustrating, but insurers look at the big picture, not just your record. I’ve seen folks get rate hikes after a hailstorm two towns over... makes you wonder sometimes.


Reply
vintage_shadow
Posts: 6
(@vintage_shadow)
Active Member
Joined:

I’ve seen folks get rate hikes after a hailstorm two towns over... makes you wonder sometimes.

- Yep, happened to me last year. Not a single scratch on my car, but my zip code got hit with “risk adjustments.”
- Feels like I’m paying for my neighbor’s bad luck... or their cousin’s, three blocks away.
- And don’t get me started on “commuter” rates. I drive a lot, but somehow, my premium jumps if someone else rear-ends a mailbox nearby?
- Insurance math is basically sorcery at this point.


Reply
cyclist19
Posts: 6
(@cyclist19)
Active Member
Joined:

Insurance math is basically sorcery at this point.

That’s honestly the best way I’ve heard it put. Last spring, our minivan sat untouched in the garage while a freak hailstorm trashed cars on the other side of town. Next renewal, our premium jumped “due to increased area risk.” I called to ask why, and the rep just kept repeating, “It’s based on statistical models.” Felt like talking to a magic 8-ball.

I get that they have to spread out risk somehow, but it’s tough not to feel like you’re footing the bill for stuff you had nothing to do with. The commuter thing gets me too—my wife drives to work every day, but we’re careful drivers. Still, one fender-bender nearby and suddenly we’re “higher risk”? Doesn’t always add up.

Guess all we can do is shop around and hope the next company’s “sorcery” works out a little better for us. Hang in there—it’s not just you scratching your head over this stuff.


Reply
Posts: 11
(@andrew_allen)
Active Member
Joined:

Insurance companies love to lump everyone together, and it drives me nuts. I’ve got a ‘72 Chevelle that barely leaves the garage, but my rates still creep up every year because of “regional risk.” It’s like they don’t care if you’re careful or your car’s a garage queen. Honestly, you’re not alone—most of us are just along for the ride with this stuff. Only real move is to keep shopping around and reading the fine print. Sometimes you get lucky, sometimes you don’t...


Reply
retro_bailey
Posts: 10
(@retro_bailey)
Active Member
Joined:

Deductibles And Premiums—What's The Real Deal?

- Can totally relate to the pain here. Got a 911 that spends more time under its cover than on the road, but my premium keeps climbing like it's out there drag racing every weekend.
- “Regional risk” is such a catch-all. Apparently, just because my zip code had a few claims, suddenly my car’s a magnet for trouble? Meanwhile, I’m over here babying it with ceramic coating and parking diagonally in empty lots.
- Tried the “low mileage” discount route. They gave me like $4 off per month. Four bucks… that’s not even a fancy coffee around here.
- Funny thing, I asked my agent if having a dashcam or security system would help. She basically shrugged and said it “might” make a difference at renewal. Might? Thanks for the confidence boost...
- Shopping around is exhausting but sometimes worth it. Last year I switched after seeing my old company sneak in a $200 hike with no explanation besides “market conditions.” New place is cheaper—for now.
- Deductibles are another circus. Raise it, they lower your premium by $10/month… until you need to use it and suddenly you’re out $2k because some squirrel decided to use your hood as a trampoline.
- Sometimes I wonder if they just spin a wheel with numbers on it when setting these rates.

Not saying there aren’t reasons behind some of this stuff, but man, owning something nice and barely driving it shouldn’t feel like you’re funding the insurance CEO’s new yacht. Maybe one day they’ll actually look at how we use our cars instead of just our addresses and what everyone else is doing nearby... but I’m not holding my breath.


Reply
Page 24 / 48
Share:
Scroll to Top