Notifications
Clear all

Rental car insurance: worth it or just a money grab?

57 Posts
56 Users
0 Reactions
205 Views
Posts: 19
(@retro314)
Active Member
Joined:

You really nailed it with the point about how confusing the whole process is. I’ve spent more time than I care to admit reading through insurance policies, and it’s wild how much overlap there can be—especially if you’ve got a decent auto policy or one of those premium credit cards. The “loss of use” thing is a perfect example; it sounds intimidating, but it’s often quietly covered if you know where to look.

Taking photos before driving off is a smart move. I’ve done the same, especially after hearing horror stories from friends who got dinged for pre-existing dings. It’s amazing how quickly a timestamped photo can shut down a bogus claim.

I do wish rental companies were more upfront about what’s actually necessary. It sometimes feels like they’re banking on people’s uncertainty. Still, I get why some folks just pay for the extra coverage—sometimes you just want to get on the road without worrying about fine print. But yeah, doing a little homework ahead of time can save a lot of hassle and money.


Reply
Posts: 14
(@hunter_evans)
Active Member
Joined:

I do wish rental companies were more upfront about what’s actually necessary. It sometimes feels like they’re banking on people’s uncertainty.

That’s exactly what gets me every time—just the sheer uncertainty of it all. I always wonder, is it really worth risking a big bill just to save a few bucks on coverage? I’ve got solid auto insurance, and my credit card supposedly covers rentals, but there’s always that nagging “what if” in the back of my mind. Has anyone actually had to file a claim through their credit card for a rental? I keep hearing it’s a paperwork nightmare.

Taking photos is non-negotiable for me now. One time, I missed a tiny scratch on the bumper and spent weeks arguing with the company over it. Ever since, I basically do a mini photo shoot before I even start the engine. Maybe it’s overkill, but I’d rather be safe than sorry.

I get why some folks just pay for the extra coverage, even if it feels like a money grab. Peace of mind is hard to put a price on, especially if you’re traveling somewhere unfamiliar. Still, I wish there was a clearer way to know when you’re actually covered and when you’re just doubling up for no reason.


Reply
jake_lee7143
Posts: 4
(@jake_lee7143)
New Member
Joined:

I hear you on the photo thing—my phone’s full of random close-ups of rental car dings and hubcaps. Once in Utah, I skipped the extra insurance, figured my card had me covered. Ended up with a cracked windshield from a rogue pebble. The claim process was... not fun. Took forever, lots of back-and-forth emails, and I had to pay upfront before getting reimbursed. Honestly, sometimes that “peace of mind” surcharge starts to make sense, especially if you’re on a tight schedule or just don’t want the hassle.


Reply
phoenixrunner109
Posts: 4
(@phoenixrunner109)
New Member
Joined:

Honestly, sometimes that “peace of mind” surcharge starts to make sense, especially if you’re on a tight schedule or just don’t want the hassle.

That’s exactly what gets me every time. I always wonder, is it really worth paying double just to avoid a headache later? I’ve had one trip where I declined the coverage, and sure enough, someone scraped the bumper in a parking lot. Sorting it out with my own insurance was a pain—tons of calls, and I was out the money for weeks. But then again, most times nothing happens and it feels like wasted cash. Does anyone actually read those rental policies in detail? Half the time I’m not even sure what’s covered.


Reply
Posts: 7
(@diy_joseph)
Active Member
Joined:

I hear you on the fine print—half the time I’m just nodding along at the counter, hoping I’m not missing something important. Last year, I skipped the extra insurance because my credit card supposedly covered rentals. Ended up with a cracked windshield from a flying rock, and it took forever to get reimbursed. Felt like I saved money upfront but paid for it in stress. Still, when nothing happens, it does feel like tossing cash away... tough call every time.


Reply
Page 6 / 12
Share:
Scroll to Top