Notifications
Clear all

Are Loyalty Perks With Insurers Even Worth It Anymore?

103 Posts
100 Users
0 Reactions
1,445 Views
Posts: 18
(@sewist56)
Eminent Member
Joined:

Honestly, I get where you’re coming from. I’ve been with the same company for over a decade now. Every time someone tells me to shop around, I think about the hassle and just... don’t bother. They’ve taken care of me when it mattered—like, one time I got rear-ended and they sorted everything out without making me jump through hoops. That kind of thing sticks with you.

Sure, maybe I’m paying a little more than if I switched every year, but I’d rather not gamble on some random company just to save a few bucks. Not saying loyalty always pays off—some companies really don’t care—but if you’ve got one that treats you right, it’s hard to put a price on that peace of mind. Guess it’s one of those “if it ain’t broke” situations for me.


Reply
Posts: 6
(@mpaws85)
Active Member
Joined:

I get the peace of mind angle, but I’ve seen too many friends stick with their insurer out of habit and then find out they’re paying way more than they should. Loyalty’s nice, but sometimes it’s just inertia. I’d at least check rates every couple years—doesn’t mean you have to switch, but it keeps them honest. That said, if your company actually comes through when it counts, that’s worth something. Just gotta watch they don’t start taking you for granted.


Reply
summitr48
Posts: 14
(@summitr48)
Active Member
Joined:

Yeah, I totally get what you’re saying. I used to just let my policy auto-renew because it felt easier, but then I realized I was missing out on better deals. Now, every year before my renewal, I do a quick comparison—takes like 20 minutes online. If my current insurer is still competitive, cool, but if not, I’ll switch. Loyalty perks are nice, but honestly, saving money matters more to me as a student. Just gotta keep an eye on those rates or they’ll creep up without you noticing.


Reply
Posts: 12
(@music217)
Active Member
Joined:

I hear you on the auto-renew thing—it’s just so easy to let it roll over, especially when life gets busy. I used to stick with my insurer for years because they threw in “VIP” perks, but honestly, most of it was just fluff. Once I actually compared quotes, I realized I’d been paying a premium for a fancy-sounding roadside service I never used. Now I shop around every renewal, even with a higher-end car. Sometimes the so-called loyalty perks don’t stack up to real savings, at least in my experience.


Reply
woodworker79
Posts: 19
(@woodworker79)
Active Member
Joined:

Loyalty perks always sound fancier than they actually are, don’t they? I remember sticking with the same company for nearly a decade because they sent me a “gold member” card in the mail. I thought I was special—turns out, all it got me was a slightly shinier envelope and a keychain I lost in my glovebox. Meanwhile, my neighbor switched every year and bragged about his savings over BBQ.

I get the appeal of just letting things auto-renew, especially when life’s throwing curveballs. But after I finally sat down and did the math, I realized I’d basically been paying extra for a “concierge” service that amounted to someone reading me the same script as everyone else. Now I check quotes every year, and honestly, I haven’t noticed any drop in service. The only thing I miss is that gold card... but my wallet’s happier without it.


Reply
Page 14 / 21
Share:
Scroll to Top